Laithwaites Basket

Global Basket / Cart - Some subtitle

About Laithwaites

Laithwaites is a leading direct-to-consumer wine retailer operating across three core markets: the UK, US, and APAC region. The company owns 17 transactional websites, enabling localized shopping experiences while maintaining a strong digital presence globally. Originally founded as a traditional wine merchant, Laithwaites has evolved into a major online wine retailer specializing in curated selections, subscription services, and direct delivery to customers.

ROLE

Digital Product Design Lead

TEAM

Digital Product

PROJECT

LW, Avery's, BBC Good Food, WSJ, Omaha Steaks Wine, Australian Wines, TCM Wines

TOOLS

Laithwaites Basket Transformation

The Laithwaites basket project was a critical UX and system upgrade focused on refining one of the most conversion-sensitive parts of the customer journey. Unlike minor UI lifts, this was a structural and behavioural rethink — designed to simplify the experience, reduce bounce, and make the checkout path more seamless across devices.

Our basket had grown fragmented over time, with inconsistent behaviour between desktop and mobile, unclear CTAs, and overlapping error states. This initiative tackled all of that, while also aligning the basket with our new frontend framework and design system.

Goals

Simplify the Basket Experience

Strip back unnecessary complexity, reduce steps, and remove blockers to improve clarity and focus across all breakpoints.

Reduce Bounce & Abandonment

Identify friction points and fix high-abandonment triggers, especially around multi-line orders, unclear stock messaging, or cross-device drop-off.

Improve Accessibility & Consistency

Make layout, controls, and behaviour consistent across mobile and desktop — with full keyboard/screen reader accessibility.

Support New Fulfilment Logic

Integrate new systems for mixed stock types (e.g. pre-order, out of stock, multi-warehouse) with clearer rules and warnings.

Enable Component Reuse

Structure the basket as modular components that fit within the broader design system, streamlining dev and design effort.

Support the CommerceTools Migration

Redesign basket architecture to align with CommerceTools' capabilities — enabling a future-ready, decoupled solution that scales globally.

The Starting Point

efore diving into the redesign of the basket, we began by auditing the existing experience (pictured here). While this layout had been functional for some time, it showed clear signs of age: cluttered UI, inconsistent hierarchy, and a lack of mobile responsiveness. It was also missing accessibility considerations and brand cohesion. This visual represents the original design we inherited—not something we created—but it provided a critical baseline for identifying pain points, technical constraints, and opportunities to align the experience more closely with modern ecommerce standards and user expectations.

Research & Discovery

This redesign was built on a deep foundation of research, drawn from diverse sources and user insights. We pulled together existing knowledge, commissioned audits, and collected first-hand feedback across three key markets — UK, US, and Australia.H

Baymard Institute Guidance

Core UX guidance from the Baymard Institute informed our earliest thinking — particularly around clarity of micro-interactions, visibility of basket access, and frictionless progress to checkout.

Their research highlights the importance of persistent mini-basket visibility, intuitive add-to-cart confirmations, and reducing “dead ends” after product actions.

Competitor Benchmarking (UK / US / AU)

We conducted a wide benchmarking study across more than 40 retailers, supermarkets, and DTC brands in our key markets. We focused on their add-to-basket journeys, mini-basket behaviour, and checkout visibility.

This helped us identify common pain points — like modal overload or inconsistent triggers — and highlight best-in-class solutions from the likes of ASOS, Amazon, and John Lewis.

Add-to-Basket Behaviour Audit

Using examples from Baymard and leading retailers, we reviewed common approaches to add-to-basket UX: inline toasts, mini-basket pop-outs, confirmations with cross-sell, and more.

The goal was to understand how visual feedback impacts confidence — and how we could speed up decision-making without introducing unnecessary complexity.

Existing Behavioural Insights (via FullStory)

We reviewed analytics across ~63,000 user sessions from UK, US, and AU — broken down by new vs. returning user, device type, and engagement hotspots. Key insights:

Mobile vs Desktop Behaviour

  • Mobile had significantly lower scroll depth and higher median drop-off before reaching lower basket items or the checkout CTA
  • Desktop users exhibited more exploratory behaviour, engaging with multiple items and interacting with both the quantity selectors and CTAs.

Primary Interaction Zones

  • The vast majority of user clicks clustered around the checkout button and remove/edit item areas.
  • Click-through to checkout was relatively healthy, with ~70% of users who clicked "Checkout" on mobile going on to convert in the same session.

Friction Points

  • On desktop, despite a higher scroll depth (median fold ~745px), visibility of trust signals and total savings remained suboptimal in some layouts.
  • Several sessions revealed users repeatedly adjusting quantities and toggling between mobile “Chat” features and the basket without completing checkout — suggesting some decision anxiety or UI distraction.

Our design approach

Rather than applying cosmetic changes, we approached the basket as a functional experience — rethinking hierarchy, visibility, and interaction across both mobile and desktop. Early findings shaped a structure-first approach, prioritising clarity, feedback, and ease of action.

We built out rapid wireframes to test layout logic and user flow, then moved into visual refinement. Key improvements included: surfacing key pricing information earlier, improving subtotal and CTA positioning, and ensuring product updates were clearly reflected post-interaction.

On mobile, we focused heavily on scannability and spatial awareness, ensuring that users could see what they added, understand the value, and move seamlessly to checkout. The final design brought visual clarity, consistency,

Interpreting the Early Metrics

These results reflect performance 19 days post-launch, a period where behavioural shifts typically begin but haven't yet stabilised. Despite this, early signs were promising: Average Order Value rose by 7.4% to £109.26, Bounce Rate dropped by 11.5%, and Sales increased by 2.5%, adding over £19.6K in revenue. While conversion dipped slightly by 4.6%, it held steady at 16% — a strong outcome given the scale of structural change. Visits remained flat, confirming no disruption to traffic. Overall, the data validated our design hypotheses: clearer hierarchy, modularity, and trust cues led to stronger engagement and commercial lift.

Post launch stability

Since the homepage redesign, ongoing analytics show that performance has held steady. There have been no major drops in traffic, engagement, or conversion, despite new campaigns being layered in weekly by non-technical teams. This confirms not just the success of the design itself, but the effectiveness of the modular system we implemented — allowing flexibility without sacrificing user experience. Internal teams have now adopted the homepage framework as a standard template, and performance trends continue to reflect healthy usage patterns across markets.

What we improved

Consistent Global Design

We unified previously fragmented carts across the UK, US, and AU into one cohesive global product, ensuring every user encounters the same streamlined and branded experience.

Cleaner, Structured UI

The interface was redesigned from the ground up with clarity in mind—introducing stronger layout hierarchy, better spacing, and visual simplicity aligned with our design system.

Responsive by Design

The new cart adapts seamlessly across devices, offering a smooth, intuitive experience whether on desktop, tablet, or mobile.

Bigger Baskets, Stronger Buying Intent

Customers are purchasing more items per order (+0.9 units), and those who add to their basket are significantly more likely to convert (+7.3pp), showing clearer intent and a more confident path to purchase.

More Decisive and Focused Cart Use

Engagement with the cart is sharper: users are editing baskets more intentionally, with increased removal activity and focused interaction on quantity adjustments — all indicating a more streamlined decision-making process.

Sustained Engagement with Key Features

Interest in elements like Subscribe & Save and product information has held steady, and layout improvements (e.g., sticky summary) have enhanced usability, especially on desktop where users now reach key info with less effort.